查看完整版本: 看完喷血的《赤壁》

场面拍摄得还挺大气的，但对比小说有很大出入

现在的电影，导演就是随意拍拍，观众也就随意看看得了啊

刚才开了【赤壁】下，感觉好肤浅，恶心的特效  恶心的对白。
半拖半拉的看完了  :wad19

赤壁嘛，其实内容和对白，都不必过于计较
不过当年还是在电影院去看的，觉得基本值回票价吧
因为画面、场景很壮观，唯美。
演员很雷的表演，其实也不错啊，至少不落俗套

不錯的帖就要頂，才有更多好帖....大大的分享令人流連忘返 [url=http://y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://www.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a401.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a402.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a403.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a404.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a405.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a406.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a407.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a408.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a409.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a410.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a411.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a412.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a413.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a414.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a415.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a416.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a417.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a418.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a419.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a420.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a421.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a422.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a423.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a424.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a425.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a426.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a427.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a428.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a429.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a430.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a431.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a432.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a433.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a434.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a435.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a436.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a437.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a438.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a439.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a440.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a441.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a442.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a443.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a444.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a445.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a446.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a447.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a448.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a449.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a450.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a451.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a452.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a453.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a454.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a455.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a456.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a457.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a458.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a459.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a460.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a461.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a462.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a463.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a464.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a465.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a466.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a467.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a468.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a469.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a470.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a471.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a472.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a473.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a474.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a475.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a476.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a477.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a478.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a479.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a480.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a481.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a482.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a483.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a484.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a485.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a486.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a487.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a488.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a489.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a490.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a491.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a492.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a493.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a494.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a495.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a496.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a497.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a498.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a499.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a500.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a501.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a502.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a503.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a504.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a505.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a506.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a507.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a508.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a509.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a510.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a511.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a512.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a513.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a514.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a515.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a516.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a517.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a518.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a519.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a520.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a521.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a522.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a523.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a524.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a525.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a526.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a527.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a528.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a529.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a530.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a531.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a532.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a533.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a534.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a535.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a536.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a537.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a538.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a539.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a540.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a541.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a542.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a543.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a544.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a545.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a546.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a547.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a548.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a549.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a550.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a551.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a552.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a553.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a554.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a555.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a556.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a557.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a558.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a559.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a560.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a561.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a562.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a563.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a564.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a565.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a566.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a567.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a568.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a569.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a570.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a571.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a572.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a573.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a574.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a575.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a576.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a577.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a578.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a579.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a580.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a581.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a582.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a583.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a584.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a585.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a586.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a587.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a588.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a589.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a590.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a591.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a592.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a593.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a594.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a595.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a596.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a597.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a598.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a599.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a600.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a601.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a602.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a603.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a604.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a605.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a606.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a607.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a608.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a609.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a610.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a611.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a612.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a613.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a614.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a615.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a616.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a617.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a618.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a619.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a620.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a621.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a622.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a623.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a624.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a625.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a626.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a627.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a628.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a629.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a630.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a631.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a632.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a633.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a634.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a635.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a636.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a637.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a638.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a639.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a640.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a641.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a642.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a643.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a644.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a645.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a646.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a647.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a648.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a649.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a650.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a651.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a652.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a653.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a654.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a655.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a656.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a657.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a658.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a659.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a660.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a661.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a662.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a663.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a664.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a665.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a666.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a667.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a668.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a669.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a670.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a671.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a672.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a673.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a674.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a675.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a676.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a677.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a678.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a679.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a680.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a681.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a682.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a683.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a684.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a685.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a686.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a687.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a688.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a689.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a690.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a691.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a692.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a693.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a694.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a695.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a696.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a697.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a698.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a699.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://a700.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://b1.w0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://b2.w0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://b3.w0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://b4.w0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://b5.w0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://b1.x0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://b2.x0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://b3.x0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://b4.x0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://b5.x0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://b1.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://b2.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://b3.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://b4.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://b5.y0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://b1.z0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://b2.z0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://b3.z0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://b4.z0800.com/] [/url] [url=http://b5.z0800.com/] [/url]

萌萌，站起来，站起来…我了个去，两版三国演义连续剧都比这要强，忍着吐饭的冲动看完上部，下部是无论如何也不敢看了，我还是看《下水道美人鱼》吧，这比《赤壁》要轻松些，也没那么恶心和恐怖！

那些所谓的名导把中国的名著改的惨不忍睹,实在让人看不下去

食色性也....君王没有哪个不好色的..后宫佳丽三千

说实话，我只看了赤壁的上半部分，只看了金城武演的诸葛亮，我就索然无味再看后来的了。
你看的这肯定是下集，真很搞笑哈。毕竟，这就是部商业片，我觉得央视拍的最早的那部三国演义还是比较接近原著的，想了解下历史，可以看看那部三国演义。
吴宇森，呵呵，一个美国人拍中国的四大名著，还是一部商业片，你觉得会贴近历史吗？
就当周末娱乐吧，以后凡事商业片拍出来的历史名著，建议还是不要看了
就算看，也抱着放松娱乐的心情看吧，追寻历史在你心里的影子恐怕是不可能了。

其实我觉得赤壁挺好的，本身吴宇森就没有把赤壁作为一个历史片来拍，真正尊重史诗的就没有草船借箭，没有孔明借风，也没有楼主所不满的关二哥的人影，那就真的不好玩了。赤壁说这场三国最大的战役之一是为小乔打的，夸张是有，但在于艺术创作，也无不可，剧中人物个性鲜明，少了些威严，但是多了丝人性，虽然我也觉得孙尚香太无厘头，但作为一部娱乐片，没有必要上纲上线，

看完三国演义以后，感觉其它版本的三国基本都是垃圾，可能是因为先入为主造成的吧
特别是新版的三国，看到20集后再也看不下去了

赤壁啊，绝对比较牛逼，:excellence

哈哈，楼主观影很认真啊，分析的也很透彻，不过国产大片就这样，忍了吧

娱乐大片，看的痛快不就可以了吗？主要我是为了看美女主角的~哈哈

这部片子不要以历史的观点去看，电影本身就是一种允许有夸张的艺术

商业片的局限性，现在的导演拿Zf资助拍烂片，骗票房的多了。

*** 作者被禁止或删除 内容自动屏蔽 ***

还好吧，非要把它当历史剧作的话2个小时实在是不够，娱乐而已，娱乐而已，不过现在的电影太缺乏创新了，动不动拿本小说改改，或是整个老剧翻拍，无聊透顶！

中国电影糊弄观众糊弄人民糊弄智商，坐地收钱！！！

其实让人很被雷到，笑笑后却很悲伤，毕竟古典被玷污了，改了太多。:teeth